COMMON SOURCES OF ERROR IN MEASUREMENT OF LINES.
1. Not
pulling tape taut.
2.
Careless plumbing.
3-
Incorrect alignment.
4.
Effect of wind.
5.
Variation in temperature.
6.
Erroneous length of tape.
COMMON MISTAKES IN READING AND RECORDING MEASUREMENTS.
1.
Failure to observe the position of the zero point
of the tape. (In some tapes it is not at the end of the ring.)
2.
Omitting a whole chain- or tape-length.
3.
Reading from wrong end of chain, as 40 metre. for
60 metre., or in
the wrong direction from a tag, as 47 metre.
for 53 metre.
4.
Transposing figures, e.g., 46.24 for 4642
(mental); or reading
tape upside down, e.g., 6 for 9, or 86
for 98
5.
Reading wrong foot-mark, as 48.92 for 47.92.
AVOIDING MISTAKES. — Mistakes in counting the tape lengths may be avoided if more than
one person keeps the tally. Mistakes of reading the wrong foot-mark may be
avoided by noting not only the foot-mark preceding, but also the next following
foot-mark, as, "46.84 ... 47 metre," and also by holding the tape so
that the numbers are right side up when being read.
In calling off distances to the note keeper,
the tapeman should be systematic and always call them distinctly and in such terms
that they cannot be mistaken. As an instance of how mistakes of this kind occur,
suppose a tape man calls, "Forty nine, three"; it can easily be
mistaken for "Forty-nine metre." The note keeper should repeat the
distances aloud so that the tapeman may know that they were correctly
understood. It is frequently useful in doubtful cases for the note keeper to
use different words in answering, which will remove possible ambiguity. For
example, if the tapeman calls, "Thirty-six, five," the note keeper
might answer, "Thirty-six and a half." If the tapeman had meant 36.05
the mistake would be noticed.
The
tapeman should have called in such a case, "Thirty-six naught five."
The following is a set of readings which will be easily misinterpreted unless
extreme care is taken in calling them off.
47.0 —
"Forty seven naught."
40.7 —
"Forty and seven."
40.07 —
"Forty, — naught seven."
'All of
these might be carelessly called off, "Forty-seven."
In all cases the tapemen should make mental
estimates of the distances when measuring, in order to avoid large and absurd mistakes.
Accuracy Required. — If, in a survey, it is allowable to make an error of one metre in
every five hundred metre the chain is sufficiently accurate for the work. To
reach an accuracy of 1 in 1000 or greater with a chain it is necessary to give
careful attention to the pull, the plumbing, and the deviation from the standard
length. With the steel tape an accuracy of 1 in 5000 can be obtained without
difficulty if ordinary care is used in plumbing and aligning, and if an
allowance is made for any considerable error in the length of the tape. For
accuracy greater than about 1 in 10,000 it is necessary to know definitely the
temperature and the tension at which the tape is of standard length and to make
allowance for any considerable variation from these values. While the actual deviation
from the IS Standard
under
certain conditions may be 1 in 10,000, still a series of measurements of a line
all taken under similar conditions may check themselves with far greater
precision.
Amount of Different Errors. The surveyor should have a clear idea of the effects of the different
errors on his results. For very precise work they should be accurately
determined, but for ordinary work it is sufficient to know approximately the
amount of each of them. A general idea of the effect of these errors will be
shown by the following.
Pull. - At the
tension ordinarily used the light steel tape will stretch between o.o1 and 0.02
metre in 100 metre if the pull is increased 10 kg. Since the amount of stretch
is different, however, for different tapes it is advisable to investigate it by
fastening the ring of the tape to a nail in the floor and, with the tape lying
flat, applying different tensions. The tensions should be measured with a
spring balance and the variations in length under these different tensions may
be determined from the tape readings of some reference point marked on the
floor near the 100 metre end of the tape. In this manner the length of any particular
tape for any given tension may be found.
Temperature. — The
average coefficient of expansion for a steel tape is nearly 0.0000063 for 1° F.
Hence a change of temperature of 15° produces nearly o.o1 metre change in the
length of the tape. Tapes are usually manufactured to be of standard length at
62° F. and under a tension of 12 kgf. while supported throughout their length.
When great accuracy is demanded the temperature of the tape must be determined
and the corresponding temperature correction applied to the measurements.
Small
tape thermometers are made especially for this purpose. The thermometer bulb
should be in contact with the tape so as to obtain as nearly as possible the
temperature of the steel. Even under these conditions it is difficult to
determine the true temperature if the tape is exposed to sunlight.
Alignment. — The
error in length due to poor alignment can be calculated from the approximate
formula.
c - a = h²/2xc
where h
is the distance of the end of the tape from the line, c is the length of the
tape, and a is the distance along the straight line. For example, if one end of
a 50 metre tape is held 1 metre to one side of the line the error produced in
this tape-length will be
1²/2x50 = 0.01 metre
(about 10 mm).
The
correction to be applied to the distance when the two ends of the tape are not
at the same level, as when making slope measurements, is computed in the same
way.
Sag. — If a tape is
suspended only at the ends it will hang in a curve which is known as the
"catenary." On account of this curvature the distance between the end
points is evidently less than the length of the tape. The amount of this
shortening, called the effect of sag, depends upon the weight of the tape, the'
distance between the points of suspension, and the pull exerted at the ends of
the tape. With a 12 kg. pull on an ordinary
50 metre
steel tape supported at the ends the effect of sag is from 0.01 metre to 0.02
metre. The most practical way to eliminate the effect of sag, however, is to
determine by actual test the length between the end marks of the suspended tape
as follows:
In the right triangle,
c² - a² = h²
(c-a)(c+a)
= h²
Assuming
c = a and applying it to the first parenthesis only,
2c
(c-a) = h²
(approximately)
c - a =
h²/2c (approximately)
Similarly c - a = h²/2a (approximately)
It is
evident that the smaller h is in
comparison with the other two sides the more exact will be the results obtained
by this formula. This formula is correct to the nearest 1/100 metre , even when
h = 14 metre and a = 100 metre, or when h = 30 metre and a = 300 metre.
First, while the tape is supported its whole
length mark is end points while a pull of 12 kg is exerted. Then establish two
points, by means of the transit or a plumb-line, at the same distance apart,
but in such positions that the tape may be tested while supported at the ends
only. Then determine the pull necessary to bring the end marks of the suspended
tape to coincide with these reference marks. If this tension is always applied then
the two ends of the suspended tape will be the same distance apart as the ends
of the supported tape were under a 12 kg pull. If the supported tape is not of
standard length when a 12 kg pull is used this error should be allowed for in all
measurements. Or, if preferred, the reference marks just mentioned may be
placed exactly 30 metre apart and the amount of pull required to make the
suspended tape correct may be determined.
ACCURACY
OF MEASURMENTS. - In surveying we are dealing entirely with
measurements. Since absolute accuracy can never be attained, we are forced to
make a careful study of the errors of measurement. Extremely accurate
measurements are expensive, and the cost of making the survey usually limits its
accuracy. On the other hand, if a given degree of accuracy is required, the
surveyor must endeavor to do the work at a minimum cost. In most surveys
certain measurements are far more important than others and should therefore be
taken with more care than the relatively unimportant measurements. The surveyor
should distinguish carefully between errors which are of such a nature that
they tend to balance each other and those which continually accumulate. The
latter are by far the more serious. Suppose that a line 1500 metre long is
measured with a steel tape which is 0.01 metre too long and that the error in measuring
a tape-length is, say, 0.02 metre, which may of course be a + or a - error.
There will then be 50 tape-lengths in the 1500 metre line. A study of the laws
governing the distribution of accidental errors (Method of Least Squares) shows
that in such a case as this the number of errors that will probably remain
uncompensated is the square root of the total number of opportunities for
error, i.e., in the long run this would be true. Hence the total number of such
uncompensated errors in the line is 7;